Species: Peacocks!
Subspecies: bipolar disorder.
I've had the extaordinary experience this year of encountering in three friends an illness that may be more prevalent and telling about the roles of delusional thinking, hyperbole, and lying in language; about cruelty, energy, irresponsibility, and mood; about messianic ego and social chaos. One friend has been on meds for 25 years--you would never guess; in another, untreated, "wild ass" by his own account and some minor troubles with the law, but, hey, that's what we call "a character"; and the third -- crashed his 50k Mustang, transiting fast, possibly with the help of a boot, out of six-figure job, deep in debt, sinking fast, talking about "creative financing" (believe me, I don't want to know about it).
One or two out of three sound like anyone you know?
Black and white reasoning, magical thinking, extraordinary egotism, chaotic states of affairs, Big Talk, uncontained emotions -- here is a nexus not to be missed in behavior, language, politics, and psychology.
* * *
I am certain within the context of the Islamic Small Wars that conflict need not be confined to viewing through the prism of mutual contempt.
Hussein, you know "One scholar is more powerful against the devil than one thousand worshippers"; my co-religionists know that valid and reliable data may yet belie a false hypothesis, and we consequently needs must approach the development of knowledge and testing of theories from multiple directions.
Islam in its bipoloar aspect and medieval character may be wrestling with four critical language issues: 1) prevalence of and possible preference for biased, patronizing, and restricted information, often officially endorsed, plus inexcusable and widespread illiteracy (Pakistan after 62 years--50 percent); 2) rejection in speech of culpability and responsibility for internal fault; 3) consequent assignment to "dirty kaffir American Zionazi Dutch cartoonists", among others, for all that can't, doesn't, and won't work in policy; 4) disengenuous hyperbole, "big talk", speech so passionately self-serving as to lock its promoters into untenable personal and political positions.
In Somalia alone, about 1,000 Islamist zealots and 9,000 "foot soldiers" with them have through their manner of language, violence, and equally merciless and thoughtless martial behaviors and hardline policies driven some 1.25 million Muslim souls from their homes and dumped them into refugee camps in Kenya and around Mogadishu. If any can come up with a western, Asian non-Muslim, much less Israeli equivalent to Al Shabaab's energetic version of wholesale contemporary barbarity, rape and rapine, do tell.
Add to the sorrows of Somalia those of Sudan (Darfur), Pakistan (especailly in the NWFP), Afghanistan (south), etc.
* * *
March 3, 2011 -- you may imagine the subjects of interest in Facebook conversations that prompted the above responses, one withheld from the community, the other posted.
The more one looks over the often bizarre rhetoric, ad hominem attacks, and "advocacy journalism" (I think we used to call that "propaganda") of far left ranting, the more certain characteristics repeat themselves.
The hardline Palestinian press, for example, seems unable to back off its trumped up olive grove perrenials or its latest wild accusations about "lethal teargass" that have been soundly dispelled. Sir Thomas More with his own head held high in the Catholic heavans -- as well as low beside the executioner's block -- would have stood against the cynical manipulation of language and law by men for ultimately profane ends: how it is that Palestinian Muslims won't stand up to their own raving lost Muslim persecutors in similar fashion, I don't know.
In the Palestinian mind, the lone alleged victim of "lethal teargas", Jawaher Abu Rahma who died in the wake of a Friday afternoon protest in Bil'in on the West Bank will be for a day or a generation (I hope not longer) a martyr useful to the familiar cause.
In the Israeli mind, also the minds of the doctors who attended her, the IDF investigators who got to a sensible story, the western readers who read critically and expect their news to hold up with all the elements hanging together, Jawaher Abu Rahma will have been killed by an overdose of Atropine administered in the hospital after misdiagnosing her condition.
In the United States, bipolar disorder affects about 2.6 percent of the population or 5.7 million people (NIMH: The Numbers Count: Mental Disorders in America). (A study involving one HMO found that of the population so diagnosed, 42 percent received treatment for it -- NIH: "The treated prevalence of bipolar disorder in a large staff-model HMO" 1998).
One may wonder what percentages may apply elsewhere, not only with "country" as the universe but perhaps also "political movement" as a unit of interest.
My first fast web search in the area defined by "bipolar disorder and politics" has produced scant relevant results, suggesting that here is a dim region in the contemporary efforts of English-speaking pundits and scholars.
As you watch this piece (source link), keep in mind personalities like Libyan dictator Quaddafi and crashing Hollywood star Charlie Sheen:
Bipolar Disorder and Substance Abuse
Uploaded by PromisesRehab. - News videos hot off the press.
Here is a thought that could stand methodical disproving: cultures and subcultures that encourage or favor one characteristic "cognitive style" over another may well load themselves with a character type that then becomes their character in aggregate.
How else start to account for the extraordinary egoism and messianic zeal so reliably prevelant in the Hollywood star population, the "mondo" pundits of the left, and the hardline gangs and tyrants who have severely constrained, controlled, and exploited the lives of constituents across a broad swath of Islam?
Right away, I would not make bipolar disorder the psychological complex that would make sense of everything having to do with autocrats and autocratic government. However "bipolar disorder in politics" may be worth a deeper look.
How is it that certain personalities rise to nearly unassaillable power in certain societies encouraging them in their madness?
For any interested in behavior, conflcit, culture, language, psychology, and politics it is a perfect, open question.
# # #